Calling for link spam reports

Alan's picture
| 9th March 2010

I see that Matt Cutts of Google is calling for link spam reports.

I'm still very troubled by this paid links issue after all these years!

I agree it's Google's right to penalise or promote any page/site in its natural listings, which represent Google's subjective opinion of relevancy.

However, the idea that all paid links are bad/"evil" is wrong in so many ways:

  • Paid links pre-date Google.
  • There is no machine-readable standard for labelling a paid link. I'll repeat that - there is no machine-readable standard for labelling a paid link.
  • Labelling paid links fails the "Does this makes sense in the absence of search engines?" ethical test. The answer may well be "Yes". (Where the answer is "No", I agree paid links are spam).
  • Labelling paid links fails the "Would I do this if search engines did not exist?" test. In fact, you have to know that Google exists, and that they mind about paid links, in order to label those paid links in the non-standard way that Google asks you to label them. This is perhaps my biggest beef with Google's approach to paid links - they actually violate one of Google's published Webmaster principles.
  • What does "paid" mean anyway? An actual exchange of cash? If you look at the top results for any hugely commercial field, say "car insurance", it's hard to believe that there is no commercial influence in the results! When all that a company does is commercial, then every link (positive or negative) to that company's site is commercial in nature.

I understand that a market in paid links arose because of Google's algorithm.

However, the irony is that in responding to that market by asking all publishers to label paid links in a non-standard way, Google violated its own principles. It started to ask publishers to adapt what they published to suit Google (because Google existed), and called them spammers if they didn't. That's the wrong way around. It's the spammers that do stuff purely because Google exists!

You might also like

Would Your Business Benefit Most From PPC or SEO?
Creating the best marketing strategy for reaching your goals means taking a step back, looking at the bigger picture, and finding out which marketing avenues are most likely to work for you. Here are five points to consider when deciding whether PPC or SEO is right for your business.
Sam Rose
On: 26th July 2019
Posted In:
SEO Best Practices for Retail Product Pages
For online retailers, perhaps the most important pages of a website are the product pages. Here I’ll go through some ideas for improving SEO on your product pages, product listing pages, and on-site search results pages.
Sam Rose
On: 17th May 2019
Posted In:
How to Align Your SEO Content with User Intent
When was the last time you reviewed your content in terms of user intent? We’re going to take a look at why you should consider the intent and buying stage of your audience when creating content, and how you can make sure each of your website pages is attracting users at different stages of the marketing funnel.
Sam Rose
On: 8th March 2019
Posted In:

Why Choose SilverDisc

Track Record Of Success

Continuously getting it right for our clients is of paramount importance and we have some great testimonies to this.


Being Google Premier Partners and Bing Select Partners gives you the assurance that we’re fully trained, that we have demonstrated exceptional account management across a range of client spends and industries, and that our track record will continue.

Thought Leaders

We see where digital marketing is heading and position our clients to meet it. For example, we are so far ahead of the SEO game that we helped Google to write their webmaster guidelines, so you can enjoy SEO success without fear of being penalised.

Ethical & Honest

We have your best interests at heart and we give it to you straight, even if that’s painful to you or us. For example, we won’t spend your money marketing a website when it’s plain to us that the money would be wasted. We look for a win-win-win …


We listen to your individual needs, identify targets and work relentlessly towards meeting them, concentrating on what’s effective.


We exist to unlock the value of technology for business, and we love what we do. We have 25 straight years in digital marketing.

Friendly, Open and Giving

These words are at the core of our values. We build strong partnerships and go out of our way to help solve problems for clients, suppliers and the wider world.

Let's Get Started

Please fill in the form below or give us a call on 01536 316100

Follow SilverDisc